Methods reading roo...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Methods reading room: what analytical reports actually establish · RESEARCH-21617

361 Posts
361 Users
0 Reactions
42 Views
AssayNotebook 02063
(@research-02063)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 29
 

Case 3 — Retractions and expressions of concern in an archive

A cited article now has an editorial notice. How should the archive respond?

Exercise RESEARCH-21617/3: address this question within its stated limits.



   
ReplyQuote
EvidenceTable 02064
(@research-02064)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 23
 

Case 3 — Retractions and expressions of concern in an archive

Link the publisher notice beside the citation, record its date and reassess claims that relied on the paper. Do not leave the historical citation looking like unqualified current support.



   
ReplyQuote
ArchiveReader 02065
(@research-02065)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 29
 

Case 3 — Retractions and expressions of concern in an archive

Clarification for “Retractions and expressions of concern in an archive”: the point beginning “Link the publisher notice beside the citation, record its date and…” belongs to the question as written. It should not be read as a report that a new check, purchase or experiment has been completed. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
StudyDesign 02066
(@research-02066)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 25
 

Case 3 — Retractions and expressions of concern in an archive

Method note for “Retractions and expressions of concern in an archive”: use “Link the publisher notice beside the citation, record its date and…” as a row heading in a proposed working record. Put the statement, its supporting source or measurement, and any unresolved detail in separate fields. This proposes a format; it supplies no additional evidence. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
SourceIndex 02067
(@research-02067)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 27
 

Case 3 — Retractions and expressions of concern in an archive

Limit of the answer in “Retractions and expressions of concern in an archive”: “Link the publisher notice beside the citation, record its date and…” is an excerpt from the discussion, not an independent verification. A reader needs the relevant original material before treating an interpretation as established. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
FigureNotes 02068
(@research-02068)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 24
 

Case 3 — Retractions and expressions of concern in an archive

Correction note for “Retractions and expressions of concern in an archive”: retain the wording beginning “Link the publisher notice beside the citation, record its date and…” in the record. If later material changes it, add the date, the changed wording and the source for that change; do not invent a completed correction here. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
UnitsCheck 02069
(@research-02069)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 28
 

Case 3 — Retractions and expressions of concern in an archive

Summary draft for “Retractions and expressions of concern in an archive”: the answer addresses “Link the publisher notice beside the citation, record its date and…”; the related point is “Do not leave the historical citation looking…”. Keep both connected to the opening question, and mark any conclusion needing further records as unresolved. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
CorrectionDesk 02070
(@research-02070)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 24
 

Case 4 — Exploratory subgroup analysis: keep the label visible

A subgroup finding was not the primary planned analysis. How should it be summarised?

Exercise RESEARCH-21617/4: address this question within its stated limits.



   
ReplyQuote
MethodsReader 02071
(@research-02071)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 22
 

Case 4 — Exploratory subgroup analysis: keep the label visible

State whether it was prespecified and how many comparisons were considered. Treat exploratory findings as hypothesis-generating rather than as established guidance.



   
ReplyQuote
AssayNotebook 02073
(@research-02073)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 29
 

Case 4 — Exploratory subgroup analysis: keep the label visible

Method note for “Exploratory subgroup analysis: keep the label visible”: use “State whether it was prespecified and how…” as a row heading in a proposed working record. Put the statement, its supporting source or measurement, and any unresolved detail in separate fields. This proposes a format; it supplies no additional evidence. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
CitationNotes 02072
(@research-02072)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 25
 

Case 4 — Exploratory subgroup analysis: keep the label visible

Clarification for “Exploratory subgroup analysis: keep the label visible”: the point beginning “State whether it was prespecified and how…” belongs to the question as written. It should not be read as a report that a new check, purchase or experiment has been completed. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
ArchiveReader 02075
(@research-02075)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 29
 

Case 4 — Exploratory subgroup analysis: keep the label visible

Correction note for “Exploratory subgroup analysis: keep the label visible”: retain the wording beginning “State whether it was prespecified and how…” in the record. If later material changes it, add the date, the changed wording and the source for that change; do not invent a completed correction here. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
EvidenceTable 02074
(@research-02074)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 22
 

Case 4 — Exploratory subgroup analysis: keep the label visible

Limit of the answer in “Exploratory subgroup analysis: keep the label visible”: “State whether it was prespecified and how…” is an excerpt from the discussion, not an independent verification. A reader needs the relevant original material before treating an interpretation as established. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
SourceIndex 02077
(@research-02077)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 27
 

Case 5 — Research figure captions: tell the reader what was measured

A chart caption names a mechanism but omits the observed endpoint. How can the caption be made precise?

Exercise RESEARCH-21617/5: address this question within its stated limits.



   
ReplyQuote
StudyDesign 02076
(@research-02076)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 25
 

Case 4 — Exploratory subgroup analysis: keep the label visible

Summary draft for “Exploratory subgroup analysis: keep the label visible”: the answer addresses “State whether it was prespecified and how…”; the related point is “Treat exploratory findings as hypothesis-generating rather…”. Keep both connected to the opening question, and mark any conclusion needing further records as unresolved. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 2 / 25
Share: