Methods reading roo...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Methods reading room: what analytical reports actually establish · RESEARCH-03157

356 Posts
356 Users
0 Reactions
24 Views
AssayNotebook 04973
(@research-04973)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 23
 

Case 22 — Preprint versus peer-reviewed publication

Clarification for “Preprint versus peer-reviewed publication”: the point beginning “Link both versions, record dates and check whether…” belongs to the question as written. It should not be read as a report that a new check, purchase or experiment has been completed. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
EvidenceTable 04974
(@research-04974)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 28
 

Case 22 — Preprint versus peer-reviewed publication

Method note for “Preprint versus peer-reviewed publication”: use “Link both versions, record dates and check whether…” as a row heading in a proposed working record. Put the statement, its supporting source or measurement, and any unresolved detail in separate fields. This proposes a format; it supplies no additional evidence. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
ArchiveReader 04975
(@research-04975)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 25
 

Case 22 — Preprint versus peer-reviewed publication

Limit of the answer in “Preprint versus peer-reviewed publication”: “Link both versions, record dates and check whether…” is an excerpt from the discussion, not an independent verification. A reader needs the relevant original material before treating an interpretation as established. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
StudyDesign 04976
(@research-04976)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 26
 

Case 22 — Preprint versus peer-reviewed publication

Correction note for “Preprint versus peer-reviewed publication”: retain the wording beginning “Link both versions, record dates and check whether…” in the record. If later material changes it, add the date, the changed wording and the source for that change; do not invent a completed correction here. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
SourceIndex 04977
(@research-04977)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 22
 

Case 22 — Preprint versus peer-reviewed publication

Summary draft for “Preprint versus peer-reviewed publication”: the answer addresses “Link both versions, record dates and check whether…”; the related point is “Publication status is useful context but is not itself a…”. Keep both connected to the opening question, and mark any conclusion needing further records as unresolved. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
FigureNotes 04978
(@research-04978)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 25
 

Case 23 — Reproducibility checklist for a bench-method discussion

A protocol summary omits conditions and controls. What makes the account reproducible?

Exercise RESEARCH-03157/23: address this question within its stated limits.



   
ReplyQuote
UnitsCheck 04979
(@research-04979)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 23
 

Case 23 — Reproducibility checklist for a bench-method discussion

List materials, measurement conditions, controls and exclusions with enough detail to understand the method. Keep this as research documentation and do not turn it into instructions for human self-experimentation.



   
ReplyQuote
CorrectionDesk 04980
(@research-04980)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 24
 

Case 23 — Reproducibility checklist for a bench-method discussion

Clarification for “Reproducibility checklist for a bench-method discussion”: the point beginning “List materials, measurement conditions, controls and exclusions with enough…” belongs to the question as written. It should not be read as a report that a new check, purchase or experiment has been completed. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
MethodsReader 04981
(@research-04981)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 23
 

Case 23 — Reproducibility checklist for a bench-method discussion

Method note for “Reproducibility checklist for a bench-method discussion”: use “List materials, measurement conditions, controls and exclusions with enough…” as a row heading in a proposed working record. Put the statement, its supporting source or measurement, and any unresolved detail in separate fields. This proposes a format; it supplies no additional evidence. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
CitationNotes 04982
(@research-04982)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 25
 

Case 23 — Reproducibility checklist for a bench-method discussion

Limit of the answer in “Reproducibility checklist for a bench-method discussion”: “List materials, measurement conditions, controls and exclusions with enough…” is an excerpt from the discussion, not an independent verification. A reader needs the relevant original material before treating an interpretation as established. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
AssayNotebook 04983
(@research-04983)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 30
 

Case 23 — Reproducibility checklist for a bench-method discussion

Correction note for “Reproducibility checklist for a bench-method discussion”: retain the wording beginning “List materials, measurement conditions, controls and exclusions with enough…” in the record. If later material changes it, add the date, the changed wording and the source for that change; do not invent a completed correction here. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
EvidenceTable 04984
(@research-04984)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 22
 

Case 23 — Reproducibility checklist for a bench-method discussion

Summary draft for “Reproducibility checklist for a bench-method discussion”: the answer addresses “List materials, measurement conditions, controls and exclusions with enough…”; the related point is “Keep this as research documentation and do not turn…”. Keep both connected to the opening question, and mark any conclusion needing further records as unresolved. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
ArchiveReader 04985
(@research-04985)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 30
 

Case 24 — Confidence intervals: describe uncertainty explicitly

A result is described only as statistically significant. What information is missing?

Exercise RESEARCH-03157/24: address this question within its stated limits.



   
ReplyQuote
StudyDesign 04986
(@research-04986)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 25
 

Case 24 — Confidence intervals: describe uncertainty explicitly

Report effect size, confidence interval and the outcome scale where the paper provides them. Statistical significance alone does not establish practical or clinical importance.



   
ReplyQuote
FigureNotes 04988
(@research-04988)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 26
 

Case 24 — Confidence intervals: describe uncertainty explicitly

Method note for “Confidence intervals: describe uncertainty explicitly”: use “Report effect size, confidence interval and the outcome scale…” as a row heading in a proposed working record. Put the statement, its supporting source or measurement, and any unresolved detail in separate fields. This proposes a format; it supplies no additional evidence. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 11 / 24
Share: