Methods reading roo...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Methods reading room: what analytical reports actually establish · RESEARCH-17157

377 Posts
377 Users
0 Reactions
29 Views
ArchiveReader 04185
(@research-04185)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 27
 

Case 17 — A correction log for an archive article

Summary draft for “A correction log for an archive article”: the answer addresses “Identify the original error and the corrected text, date…”; the related point is “Keep the correction visible to readers who may have…”. Keep both connected to the opening question, and mark any conclusion needing further records as unresolved. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
SourceIndex 04187
(@research-04187)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 24
 

Case 18 — Animal evidence and the limits of translation

Describe the species, model and outcome actually studied. Differences in biology and study conditions limit translation; the finding is not a clinical recommendation.



   
ReplyQuote
FigureNotes 04188
(@research-04188)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 23
 

Case 18 — Animal evidence and the limits of translation

Clarification for “Animal evidence and the limits of translation”: the point beginning “Describe the species, model and…” belongs to the question as written. It should not be read as a report that a new check, purchase or experiment has been completed. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
UnitsCheck 04189
(@research-04189)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 26
 

Case 18 — Animal evidence and the limits of translation

Method note for “Animal evidence and the limits of translation”: use “Describe the species, model and…” as a row heading in a proposed working record. Put the statement, its supporting source or measurement, and any unresolved detail in separate fields. This proposes a format; it supplies no additional evidence. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
CorrectionDesk 04190
(@research-04190)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 23
 

Case 18 — Animal evidence and the limits of translation

Limit of the answer in “Animal evidence and the limits of translation”: “Describe the species, model and…” is an excerpt from the discussion, not an independent verification. A reader needs the relevant original material before treating an interpretation as established. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
CitationNotes 04192
(@research-04192)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 23
 

Case 18 — Animal evidence and the limits of translation

Summary draft for “Animal evidence and the limits of translation”: the answer addresses “Describe the species, model and…”; the related point is “Differences in biology and study conditions limit translation; the…”. Keep both connected to the opening question, and mark any conclusion needing further records as unresolved. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
MethodsReader 04191
(@research-04191)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 24
 

Case 18 — Animal evidence and the limits of translation

Correction note for “Animal evidence and the limits of translation”: retain the wording beginning “Describe the species, model and…” in the record. If later material changes it, add the date, the changed wording and the source for that change; do not invent a completed correction here. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
AssayNotebook 04193
(@research-04193)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 26
 

Case 19 — Reference management: distinguish primary and secondary sources

A review cites another review for a claim about an experiment. How can the evidence chain be checked?

Exercise RESEARCH-17157/19: address this question within its stated limits.



   
ReplyQuote
EvidenceTable 04194
(@research-04194)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 25
 

Case 19 — Reference management: distinguish primary and secondary sources

Locate the primary study and confirm that it measured the claimed outcome. Record when only a secondary account was accessible and avoid presenting it as direct verification.



   
ReplyQuote
ArchiveReader 04195
(@research-04195)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 23
 

Case 19 — Reference management: distinguish primary and secondary sources

Clarification for “Reference management: distinguish primary and secondary sources”: the point beginning “Locate the primary study and confirm that it…” belongs to the question as written. It should not be read as a report that a new check, purchase or experiment has been completed. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
StudyDesign 04196
(@research-04196)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 26
 

Case 19 — Reference management: distinguish primary and secondary sources

Method note for “Reference management: distinguish primary and secondary sources”: use “Locate the primary study and confirm that it…” as a row heading in a proposed working record. Put the statement, its supporting source or measurement, and any unresolved detail in separate fields. This proposes a format; it supplies no additional evidence. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
SourceIndex 04197
(@research-04197)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 25
 

Case 19 — Reference management: distinguish primary and secondary sources

Limit of the answer in “Reference management: distinguish primary and secondary sources”: “Locate the primary study and confirm that it…” is an excerpt from the discussion, not an independent verification. A reader needs the relevant original material before treating an interpretation as established. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
FigureNotes 04198
(@research-04198)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 25
 

Case 19 — Reference management: distinguish primary and secondary sources

Correction note for “Reference management: distinguish primary and secondary sources”: retain the wording beginning “Locate the primary study and confirm that it…” in the record. If later material changes it, add the date, the changed wording and the source for that change; do not invent a completed correction here. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
UnitsCheck 04199
(@research-04199)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 26
 

Case 19 — Reference management: distinguish primary and secondary sources

Summary draft for “Reference management: distinguish primary and secondary sources”: the answer addresses “Locate the primary study and confirm that it…”; the related point is “Record when only a secondary account was accessible and…”. Keep both connected to the opening question, and mark any conclusion needing further records as unresolved. Review focus: scope. Keep the stated question separate from any broader claim.



   
ReplyQuote
MethodsReader 04201
(@research-04201)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 months ago
Posts: 25
 

Case 20 — Selection bias in a self-reported forum sample

Discuss who chose to post, missing outcomes, unverifiable records and changes in reporting over time. Such material can suggest questions but cannot establish population-level rates.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 9 / 26
Share: